Evidence claim support and contradiction review
Requires scope alignment and conflict review before a source is treated as claim support. Original worked design example; adapt responsibilities, thresholds and assumptions to your system.
Rendering…
What this template contains
- Diagram type
- Flowchart
- Source
- 16 lines
Make it your own.
flowchart TD
Q[Draft claim] --> S[Collect source passages]
S --> A{Access and provenance verified?}
A -->|No| U[Mark source unavailable]
A -->|Yes| P[Compare claim with exact passage]
P --> M{Population, outcome and qualifier match?}
M -->|No| R[Revise claim scope]
R --> P
M -->|Yes| C{Conflicting evidence found?}
C -->|Yes| B[Describe conflict and assess methods]
C -->|No| G[Record supported scope]
B --> G
G --> N{Support sufficient for intended use?}
N -->|No| H[Retain as uncertain and request evidence]
N -->|Yes| F[Publish claim with traceable support]
U --> H